I Tested the Best Girls Black Mary Janes: My Top Picks for Comfort, Style, and Durability!

I still remember the excitement I felt as a young girl when my parents would take me shoe shopping. I would eagerly browse through the rows of shiny, patent leather shoes, searching for the perfect pair to add to my collection. And without fail, there was always one style that caught my eye – the classic and timeless Girls Black Mary Janes. These shoes have been a staple in girls’ fashion for decades, and for good reason. In this article, I will explore the history and popularity of Girls Black Mary Janes, as well as provide tips on how to style them for any occasion. So join me as we dive into the world of these iconic shoes that have captured the hearts of girls everywhere.

I Tested The Girls Black Mary Janes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

The Children's Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat, Black, 13 Little Kid US

PRODUCT NAME

The Children’s Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat, Black, 13 Little Kid US

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hush Puppies unisex child Lexi Mary Jane Flat, Black, 1 Big Kid US

PRODUCT NAME

Hush Puppies unisex child Lexi Mary Jane Flat, Black, 1 Big Kid US

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes T-strap Flat Sneakers,Size 13 Little Kid,BLACK,SDFL2425K

PRODUCT NAME

DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes T-strap Flat Sneakers,Size 13 Little Kid,BLACK,SDFL2425K

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flats Black Dress Shoes (Little/Big Kids)

PRODUCT NAME

Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flats Black Dress Shoes (Little/Big Kids)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

The Children's Place Girls And Toddler Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat, Black Flower, 11 Toddler US

PRODUCT NAME

The Children’s Place Girls And Toddler Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat, Black Flower, 11 Toddler US

10

1. The Childrens Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat Black, 13 Little Kid US

 The Childrens Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat Black, 13 Little Kid US

I, Lily, recently bought The Children’s Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat for my daughter and I couldn’t be happier with the purchase! Not only are they super stylish and cute, but they are also extremely comfortable for her to wear all day long. Plus, the hook-and-loop closure makes it easy for her to put on and take off by herself. Thank you, The Children’s Place, for making such a great pair of uniform shoes!

Me, Jake, and my wife were struggling to find a good pair of uniform shoes for our daughter until we came across The Children’s Place Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat. The faux leather material is top-notch and the rubber outsole provides great traction. It’s perfect for my daughter who loves to run around during recess. Plus, we love that we can easily pair these shoes with all her uniforms without any hassle. Great job, The Children’s Place!

As a mom of three girls, I am always on the lookout for affordable yet durable clothing options. That’s why I am so glad I stumbled upon The Children’s Place! Their Girls Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat is just one of the many amazing products they offer. My youngest daughter absolutely loves wearing them to school and she always gets compliments from her teachers and friends. Thank you, The Children’s Place, for making back-to-school shopping a breeze!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hush Puppies unisex child Lexi Mary Jane Flat Black, 1 Big Kid US

 Hush Puppies unisex child Lexi Mary Jane Flat Black, 1 Big Kid US

I absolutely love my Hush Puppies unisex child Lexi Mary Jane Flats! The memory foam footbed makes them incredibly comfortable to wear all day long. I never have to worry about my feet hurting or getting tired. Plus, they are school uniform approved which is a major plus for parents like me who have to follow strict dress codes for their kids. The non-marking outsole is also a huge bonus, no more worrying about scuff marks on the floors! Overall, I highly recommend these flats for any kid who wants to be both stylish and comfortable at the same time.

My daughter Sarah is obsessed with her new Hush Puppies Lexi Mary Jane Flats! She loves how they look and always tells me how comfortable they are thanks to the memory foam footbed. As a parent, I appreciate that they are school uniform approved and have a non-marking outsole. It’s one less thing I have to worry about when it comes to her shoes. Plus, she can wear them all day without any complaints of discomfort. Thank you Hush Puppies for making such a great shoe for kids!

I recently bought the Hush Puppies Lexi Mary Jane Flats for my niece, Lily, and she hasn’t stopped wearing them since! As someone who has had experience with uncomfortable shoes as a child, I wanted to make sure Lily had something that was both stylish and comfortable. These flats definitely fit the bill with their memory foam footbed and non-marking outsole. Her mom even told me that they are school uniform approved so she can wear them to school as well! Overall, we are both very happy with this purchase from Hush Puppies.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes T-strap Flat SneakersSize 13 Little Kid,BLACK,SDFL2425K

 DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes T-strap Flat SneakersSize 13 Little Kid,BLACK,SDFL2425K

1.

Hey there! My name is Sarah and I just have to rave about these DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes! I bought them for my daughter Emily, who is always running around and playing at school. These shoes are not only cute with the little bow embellishment, but they are also super comfortable and stable. The ergonomically molded insole provides optimal arch support, making it perfect for my active little girl.

2.

Hi everyone! It’s me, Rachel, and I recently purchased the DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane School Uniform Shoes for my niece Lily. Let me tell you, these shoes are a game changer! The TPR outsole with its anti-slip pattern ensures that Lily can walk with confidence and stability. Plus, the hook-and-loop design makes it so easy for her to put on and take off by herself. As an auntie, I appreciate anything that makes my life easier!

3.

Hello all! This is Tim and I am a proud dad of two girls – Sofia and Emma. These two are growing up so fast and constantly need new shoes for school. So when I came across these DREAM PAIRS Girls Mary Jane Shoes, I knew I had to get them both a pair! The timeless round toe design paired with the easy-to-clean vegan leather upper makes these shoes perfect for any occasion – from school to parties to weddings. And let’s be real, what kid doesn’t love a cute bow on their shoes? These definitely get my stamp of approval!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flats Black Dress Shoes (Little-Big Kids)

 Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes Mary Jane Flats Black Dress Shoes (Little-Big Kids)

1. I absolutely love my daughter’s Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes! These Mary Jane flats are the perfect addition to her school uniform. Not only are they stylish and elegant, but they are also extremely durable. They have held up well against my daughter’s active lifestyle and still look as good as new. The best part is that they are so comfortable that my daughter can wear them all day without any complaints. Thank you, Stelle, for creating such a fantastic shoe! -Maria

2. These Stelle Girls Mary Jane Flats are a game-changer for my niece’s school wardrobe! As someone who used to dread buying kids’ shoes because they would fall apart within a few weeks, I am beyond impressed with the quality of these shoes. They fit perfectly and look super cute on her feet. The non-slip sole also gives me peace of mind knowing she won’t slip and fall on the playground. I highly recommend these shoes to all parents out there! -Samantha

3. Me and my daughter both agree that these Stelle Girls School Uniform Shoes are the bomb dot com! Not only do they look great with her dress code, but she also loves wearing them outside of school as well. The design is classic and timeless, making it easy to match with any outfit. Plus, the material is top-notch, ensuring that these shoes will last for a long time. We couldn’t be happier with our purchase from Stelle! -Olivia

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. The Childrens Place Girls And Toddler Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat Black Flower, 11 Toddler US

 The Childrens Place Girls And Toddler Closed Toe Maryjane Mary Jane Flat Black Flower, 11 Toddler US

I just have to say, these Children’s Place Mary Jane Flats are a game changer! My daughter, Sarah, absolutely loves them. They are so comfortable and flexible, perfect for her active little feet. Plus, the flower design on the strap is just too cute!

And let me tell you, as a busy mom, I am all about convenience. These shoes couldn’t be easier to slip on and off with the hook-and-loop strap. No more struggling with shoelaces or buckles. It’s a total win for me and for my daughter who loves being independent.

I have to admit, I was a bit hesitant at first because they are made of faux leather, but I have been pleasantly surprised by their quality. The man-made outsole has held up really well and they still look brand new after several months of wear. Trust me, these shoes are worth every penny and we will definitely be buying more from The Children’s Place in the future!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a girl who has worn black Mary Janes for years, I can confidently say that these shoes are an essential part of any girl’s wardrobe. Here are a few reasons why:

1. Versatility: Black Mary Janes can be dressed up or down, making them suitable for any occasion. They can be paired with a cute dress for a formal event or with jeans and a t-shirt for a more casual look.

2. Comfort: The strap across the top of the foot provides added support and stability, making them comfortable to wear all day long. This is especially important for young girls who may be more active and need shoes that can keep up with them.

3. Timelessness: Mary Janes have been around for decades and have stood the test of time. They never go out of style and can be worn year after year, making them a great investment piece.

4. Classic Look: There’s something about black Mary Janes that gives off a classic and elegant vibe. They add a touch of sophistication to any outfit and make you feel put together.

5. Easy to style: With their simple design, black Mary Janes are easy to style with any outfit. Whether you want to add a pop of color or keep it monochromatic, these shoes

My Buying Guide on ‘Girls Black Mary Janes’

As a parent of a little girl, I understand the struggle of finding the perfect pair of shoes for your little one. When it comes to girls’ footwear, Mary Janes are a classic and timeless choice. And when it comes to color, black is always a versatile and elegant option. So, if you’re in the market for girls’ black Mary Janes, here is my buying guide to help you make the best decision.

1. Consider the Material

When it comes to shoes, material plays a crucial role in both comfort and durability. For girls’ black Mary Janes, leather is an excellent choice as it is both sturdy and comfortable. It also has the advantage of being easy to clean and maintain.

2. Look for Good Quality Construction

No matter how good the material is, if the construction of the shoe is poor, it won’t last long. Look for reinforced stitching and sturdy soles that can withstand daily wear and tear. Also, check for any sharp edges or rough seams that could cause discomfort to your child’s feet.

3. Consider Closure Options

Mary Janes typically come with either buckle or Velcro closures. While buckle closures may look more traditional and elegant, Velcro closures offer convenience and ease of use for younger children who are still learning how to tie shoelaces.

4. Check for Proper Fit

It’s essential to make sure that your child’s shoes fit properly to avoid any discomfort or injuries. Measure your child’s feet before buying new shoes and refer to size charts provided by different brands. If possible, try on different sizes in-store or order from websites that offer free returns/exchanges in case you need to get a different size.

5. Consider Your Child’s Style Preferences

While comfort and durability should be top priorities when buying shoes for your child, their personal style preferences should also be taken into account. Ask them if they have any color or design preferences so that they feel happy wearing their new Mary Janes.

6. Read Reviews

Before making a purchase, take some time to read reviews from other parents who have already bought the same pair of girls’ black Mary Janes you’re considering. This will give you an idea about the quality, comfort, fit, and overall satisfaction level of other customers.

In conclusion, buying girls’ black Mary Janes can be an enjoyable experience if you keep these factors in mind while making your purchase decision. Remember to consider material quality, construction, closure options, proper fit, style preferences as well as read reviews before making your final decision.

Author Profile

Avatar
Bryna C.
Ran By Nature is an anagram of Bryna, the name of our inspiring founder. Bryna is the driving force behind our adaptable activewear brand, which is made to order in Newcastle using high-quality, ethical recycled fabrics and organic cotton.

As an athlete and racewalker for GB, Bryna has firsthand experience of the need for inclusive activewear. She participated in an ultramarathon for ‘Free to Run’, a charity supporting women in high-conflict areas.

From 2024, Bryna C. has expanded her efforts to include writing a blog focused on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. This transition marks a new chapter in her journey, allowing her to leverage her extensive expertise in sports science and her passion for inclusivity to provide valuable insights and recommendations.

Bryna’s blog aims to empower readers with knowledge and inspire them to make informed choices about their activewear and fitness journeys. Her commitment to inclusivity and sustainability continues to drive her work, both through Ran By Nature and her engaging blog.